Training a stubborn dog can be a challenge for any pet owner. If you have a dog that is resistant to basic obedience commands or displays undesirable behaviors, using a training collar can be an effective tool to help improve their behavior. However, with so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to determine which training collar is the best for your stubborn dog. In this article, we will discuss the different types of training collars and their effectiveness in training stubborn dogs.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs That Actually Work

PetSafe Remote Training Collar

Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe

Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar

SportDOG Brand Remote Training Collar

Educator E-Collar Remote Training Collar

PetSpy Remote Training Collar

PetTutor Remote Training Collar

Herm Sprenger Prong Collar

PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar

DogCare Rechargeable Training Collar

PetSafe Remote Training Collar

The PetSafe Remote Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs is a versatile training tool designed to help owners teach their stubborn dogs proper behavior and obedience. It features a remote control system that allows the owner to deliver a safe and gentle corrective stimulation to the dog from a distance.

Features:

Designed for stubborn dogs: This training collar is specifically designed for stubborn and hard-to-train dogs.
Remote control system: The collar comes with a remote control that allows the owner to deliver a corrective stimulation from up to 300 yards away.
Tone and vibration options: The collar offers both tone and vibration options as corrective stimuli, in addition to the traditional static stimulation.
Easy to adjust intensity levels: The intensity levels of the corrective stimulation can be easily adjusted with a few clicks on the remote control.
Waterproof and durable: The collar and remote are both waterproof and durable, making them suitable for outdoor use and in all weather conditions.
Rechargeable batteries: Both the collar and the remote are equipped with rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for constantly purchasing new batteries.

Pros:

Effective: Many users have reported that this training collar is highly effective in correcting unwanted behaviors in their stubborn dogs.
Versatile: The tone and vibration options make this training collar a versatile tool that can be used for various training needs.
Safe and gentle: The corrective stimulation is designed to be safe and gentle, ensuring the well-being of your dog during training.
Customizable intensity levels: The option to adjust the intensity levels allows owners to find the most appropriate level for their dog’s response.
Long-distance control: The remote control allows owners to deliver corrective stimulation from a distance, making it ideal for off-leash training.

Cons:

Not suitable for small dogs: This training collar may not be suitable for small dogs as it is designed for dogs weighing 8 pounds or more.
May not work for all dogs: While this training collar may be effective for many stubborn dogs, it may not work for some dogs with extreme behavioral issues.
Price: The collar may be more expensive than other options on the market, which may not be suitable for all budgets.

Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe

The Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe is a bark control collar designed for stubborn dogs. It features advanced bark correction technology and a compact, lightweight design.

Features:

Advanced Bark Correction Technology: The BarkLimiter Deluxe uses advanced technology to distinguish between barking and other vocalizations, such as whining or growling. This prevents false corrections and ensures that only excessive barking is corrected.
Automatic Correction Levels: The collar has multiple levels of automatic correction, which adjust based on the dog’s barking behavior. This eliminates the need for manual adjustments and makes it easier to find the right level for your dog.
Rechargeable Battery: The collar has a rechargeable battery that can last up to 3 months on a single charge. This eliminates the need for frequent battery replacements.
Adjustable Intensity Levels: The BarkLimiter Deluxe has 10 levels of intensity, allowing you to find the perfect level for your dog. This also ensures that the correction is strong enough to be effective for stubborn dogs.
Vibration and Tone Options: In addition to the automatic correction levels, the collar also has vibration and tone options. The vibration option can be used as a warning before the static correction, while the tone option can be used as a standalone correction for more sensitive dogs.
Comfortable and Durable Design: The collar is lightweight and has a compact design, making it comfortable for your dog to wear. It is also waterproof and durable, making it suitable for all weather conditions.

Pros:

Highly Effective: The BarkLimiter Deluxe has been proven to be highly effective in reducing excessive barking in stubborn dogs. The advanced bark correction technology ensures that only excessive barking is corrected, making it a more humane option than traditional bark collars.
Adjustable Intensity Levels: The multiple intensity levels allow for a customizable approach that can be tailored to your dog’s individual needs.
Rechargeable Battery: The rechargeable battery eliminates the need for frequent battery replacements, making the collar more convenient and cost-effective in the long run.
Vibration and Tone Options: The vibration and tone options provide alternative correction methods for more sensitive dogs, making it a versatile training tool.

Cons:

Price: The Garmin BarkLimiter Deluxe is more expensive than other bark collars on the market, but its advanced features and effectiveness make it a worthwhile investment for those with stubborn dogs.
Can be Triggered by Other Dogs: The advanced bark correction technology may also detect barking from other dogs, causing a false correction for your own dog. However, the BarkLimiter Deluxe allows you to turn off this feature if needed.
Not Suitable for Small Dogs: The collar is recommended for dogs weighing 10 pounds or more, so it may not be suitable for small breeds.

Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar

The Dogtra 1900S Remote Training Collar is a high-quality, advanced training collar designed for stubborn and hard-to-train dogs. It features durable construction, a wide range of training modes, and a long battery life, making it a popular choice among dog trainers and pet owners.

Features:

Long-range remote: The Dogtra 1900S has a range of up to ¾ mile, allowing you to train your dog from a distance.
Multiple training modes: This collar offers a variety of training modes, including nick, continuous, and vibration stimulation, as well as a non-stimulating high-performance pager.
Waterproof design: The collar and remote are both waterproof, making it suitable for use in all weather conditions.
LCD screen: The remote features a backlit LCD screen, making it easy to read in low-light conditions.
Rechargeable batteries: Both the collar and remote are rechargeable, with a long battery life of up to 40-60 hours per charge.
Customizable stimulation settings: You can adjust the stimulation level on the collar, allowing you to find the most effective level for your dog.
Enhanced contact points: The collar comes with contact points that are designed to provide consistent and reliable stimulation without causing any discomfort to your dog.
Ergonomic design: The remote is designed with user comfort in mind, with a compact and ergonomic shape that fits comfortably in your hand.

Pros:

Highly customizable: With multiple training modes, adjustable stimulation levels, and customizable contact points, the Dogtra 1900S allows you to tailor the training experience to suit your dog’s needs.
Effective for stubborn dogs: The strong stimulation and range of features make this collar suitable for even the most stubborn and hard-to-train dogs.
Durable and waterproof: The collar and remote are both built to last and can withstand harsh outdoor conditions without being damaged.
Long battery life: The rechargeable batteries of the Dogtra 1900S last for a long time, reducing the need for frequent charging.

Cons:

Higher price point: Compared to other training collars on the market, the Dogtra 1900S is on the more expensive side.
Limited stimulation levels: Some users may find that the stimulation levels offered by this collar may not be strong enough for very stubborn dogs.
Bulky remote: While the remote is designed to be ergonomic, some users may find it too bulky to comfortably hold for extended training sessions.

SportDOG Brand Remote Training Collar

The SportDOG Brand Remote Training Collar is a high-quality, durable training collar designed specifically for stubborn dogs. It offers a range of features and functions to help you train your dog effectively and safely.

Features:

Multiple Training Modes: This collar offers three different training modes – Continuous, Momentary, and Vibration. This allows you to choose the best option for your dog’s training needs.
Long Range: The remote has a range of up to 500 yards, making it ideal for working with dogs in large open spaces.
Seven Levels of Static Stimulation: The collar has seven levels of static stimulation, allowing you to choose the right level for your dog’s temperament.
Waterproof and Submersible: Both the remote and the collar are waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet, making them suitable for use in all weather conditions.
Battery Life: The collar and remote have a long battery life, with the collar lasting up to 40-60 hours and the remote up to 80-100 hours.
Safe and Humane: The static stimulation feature of this collar is designed to be safe and humane, providing a mild and adjustable correction that does not harm your dog.

Pros:

Designed for Stubborn Dogs: This collar is specifically designed for stubborn dogs, making it an ideal choice for training breeds such as German Shepherds or Pitbulls.
Wide Range of Training Options: With multiple training modes and intensity levels, this collar offers a wide range of options to suit your dog’s training needs.
Durable and Long-Lasting: The collar and remote are both durable and long-lasting, making it a worthwhile investment for your dog’s training.
Adjustable: The collar is adjustable to fit dogs of all sizes, ranging from 5 pounds to 22 inches in neck size.

Cons:

Not Suitable for Small Dogs: Due to the minimum weight requirement of 5 pounds, this collar may not be suitable for very small dogs.
Pricey: This training collar comes at a higher price point compared to other options on the market.

Educator E-Collar Remote Training Collar

The Educator E-Collar Remote Training Collar is designed specifically for stubborn dogs who require a higher level of correction during training. It is a high-quality, reliable training tool that offers a range of features to help owners effectively train their dogs.

Features:

Intensity Levels: The training collar has 100 levels of static stimulation, ranging from low to high, to suit the individual needs of different dogs.
Tone and Vibration: Along with the static stimulation, this collar also offers tone and vibration modes, providing different options for correction based on the dog’s response.
Range: The remote has a range of up to 1 mile, making it suitable for long-distance training in large open spaces.
Waterproof: Both the collar and the remote are waterproof, making it suitable for use in all weather conditions.
Ergonomic Design: The collar has a slim, ergonomic design that makes it comfortable for dogs to wear for extended periods.
Safety Features: The Educator E-Collar has several safety features, including a sleep mode to prevent accidental stimulation and a loss of signal alarm.
Rechargeable Batteries: Both the collar and remote have rechargeable batteries, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.
LCD Display: The remote has an easy-to-read LCD display, allowing for quick adjustments to the stimulation levels.

Pros:

Customizable: The 100 levels of stimulation and various modes make it easy to find the right level and method of correction for different dogs.
Long-distance range: The 1-mile range allows for effective training in a variety of outdoor settings.
Waterproof: The waterproof design makes this collar suitable for use in all weather conditions.
Safety features: The sleep mode and loss of signal alarm help to prevent accidental stimulation and ensure the dog’s safety during training.
Rechargeable: The rechargeable batteries make this collar a more cost-effective option in the long run.

Cons:

May be too powerful for some dogs: The high level of static stimulation may be too intense for some sensitive or small-breed dogs.
Expensive: Compared to other training collars, the Educator E-Collar is on the higher end of the price range.
Large remote: The remote may be too big for some users to comfortably handle.

Best Shock Collar for Large Dogs with Thick Fur

PetSafe Remote Training Collar
Garmin Delta XC Dog Training Device
Dogtra Arc Remote Training Collar
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425 Remote Trainer
PetSpy Dog Shock Collar
Educator ET-300 Mini Remote Training Collar
PetSpy M686B Remote Training Collar
PetSpy Dog Training Shock Collar
PetSpy PX-1 Dog Training Collar
Dogtra 1900S Dual Training Collar

Most Powerful Shock Collar for Large Dogs

PetSafe Remote Trainer Shock Collar
SportDOG Brand 425X Remote Training Collar
Dog Care Training Collar
PetSpy Shock Collar for Dogs
Garmin Delta XC Bundle
PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Collar
Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
PetAZ Dog Training Collar
Bousnic Dog Training Collar
TBI Pro Dog Training Collar

Best Shock Collar for Aggressive Dogs

PetSafe Remote Dog Training Collar
Garmin Delta XC Dog Training Device
Dogtra 1900S Remote Dog Training Collar
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425 Remote Dog Training System
PetSpy Dog Training Shock Collar
PetSpy M686B Dog Training Shock Collar
TBI Pro Dog Training Collar with Remote
PetSpy M919 Dog Training Shock Collar
Petrainer PET998DRB Remote Dog Training Collar

Best Shock Collar for Dogs That Run Away

PetSafe Remote Dog Training Collar
Garmin Delta XC Dog Training Collar
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainer
PetSpy Dog Training Shock Collar
Dogtra IQ Remote Trainer
Petronics Shock Training Collar
PetSpy M686 Premium Dog Training Collar
PetLevelUp Shock Collar for Dogs
Educator E-Collar Remote Dog Training Collar
TBI Pro Dog Training Collar with Remote Control

Types of Dog Training Collars

Flat Collar: This is a basic collar that is made of fabric or leather and is used for everyday wear. It is simple to put on and take off and is adjustable for a comfortable fit. This type of collar is suitable for dogs who do not have any major behavior issues and are not strong pullers.
Martingale Collar: This collar is also known as a limited-slip collar and is designed for dogs who have a tendency to slip out of their collars or have a narrow head. It consists of a fabric or chain loop that tightens when the dog pulls, preventing them from slipping out. It is not meant to choke your dog, but rather to provide a gentle reminder to stay in place.
Head Halter: A head halter consists of a strap that goes around the dog’s muzzle and another that goes around their neck, similar to a horse’s halter. It works by controlling the dog’s head movements, making it useful for dogs who tend to pull on walks or have aggression issues.
Prong Collar: A prong collar, also known as a pinch collar, has prongs that apply pressure around the dog’s neck when they pull. It is not recommended for inexperienced owners, as it can cause harm if used incorrectly. This type of collar should only be used under the guidance of a professional trainer.
Choke Collar: Similar to a prong collar, a choke collar tightens around the dog’s neck when they pull. It is not recommended for most dogs as it can cause injury and should only be used under the guidance of a professional.
Shock Collar: A shock collar, also known as an electronic collar, delivers an electric shock to the dog when a trigger is pressed. It is not recommended for training as it can cause physical and psychological harm to the dog.
Citronella Collar: This type of collar sprays a burst of citronella when a trigger is pressed, which is meant to distract and deter unwanted behavior. It is a more humane alternative to shock collars and can be helpful for training barking and other behaviors.
Vibration Collar: A vibration collar uses vibrations to get the dog’s attention, rather than a shock or spray. It can be a useful tool for dogs who are hard of hearing or for training behaviors such as recall.

Bousnic Dog Training Collar

The Bousnic Dog Training Collar is an electronic collar that is designed to help you train your dog using positive reinforcement. The collar has a remote control that allows you to send a signal to the collar, which will then deliver a small shock to your dog. The shock is not painful, but it is enough to get your dog’s attention. The collar also has a beep and vibration mode, so you can choose the best way to train your dog. The remote control has a range of up to 1,000 feet, so you can use it to train your dog from a distance.

Are Training Collars Ethical?

This is a hotly debated topic in the world of dog training. Some people believe that using training collars is unethical, as they rely on aversive methods to get your dog to obey commands. Others argue that training collars can be a useful tool when used correctly, and can help you train your dog more effectively. It is important to consider the specific collar you are using and how you are using it. Many experts recommend that you work with a trainer or behaviorist before using a training collar, to make sure that you are using it in the most ethical and effective way possible.

How Does a Training Collar Work?

A training collar is a device that is worn around a dog’s neck. The collar can deliver either a tone, vibration, or static correction when a button is pressed on a remote control that is used by the trainer. The tone and vibration are meant to get the dog’s attention and are not painful. The static correction is a small shock that is meant to startle the dog and is not meant to be painful. When used correctly, a training collar can help you teach your dog to obey commands.

How to Use Training Collars

Before you begin using a training collar, it is important to understand how to use it properly. First, you should get your dog accustomed to wearing the collar. Let them wear it around the house without turning it on, so they become comfortable with it. Once they are comfortable, you can begin using the collar to train them. Start with low levels of correction and work up slowly. Be sure to give lots of praise when your dog responds correctly. Remember to use the collar as part of a training program that includes other positive reinforcement methods, such as treats and praise.

FAQs

Q. Do shock collars work for stubborn dogs?

A. Some trainers believe that shock collars can be effective for stubborn dogs, while others do not recommend them. Shock collars are controversial because they deliver a small electrical shock to the dog when they are used.

Q. How do you train a stubborn dog?

A. Training a stubborn dog can be challenging, but it is possible. First, it is important to be patient and consistent with your training. You should also try to make training fun and rewarding for your dog. Try using positive reinforcement, such as treats or praise, to encourage good behavior. It is also important to identify the root cause of your dog’s stubbornness. For example, if your dog is stubborn because they are afraid or anxious, you will need to address those issues before you can expect your dog to respond to training. Additionally, you should try to keep your dog’s training sessions short and focused.

Q. What type of dog collar is best for training?

A. There are a variety of different types of dog collars that can be used for training. Some popular options include martingale collars, slip leads, and head halters. Martingale collars are ideal for dogs that tend to pull on the leash, as they tighten when the dog pulls and then relax when they stop pulling. Slip leads are similar to martingale collars, but they tighten around the dog’s neck instead of their chest. Head halters work by steering the dog’s head, which can be effective for training stubborn or reactive dogs.

Q. What is the best-rated dog training collar?

A. There are many different dog training collars on the market, and it can be difficult to determine which one is the best. However, there are a few highly rated options that are worth considering. The PetSafe Gentle Leader Head Collar is one of the most popular choices, as it is easy to use and effective for most dogs.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the best training collar for your stubborn dog will depend on your specific needs and preferences. It’s important to consider the features and functions of each collar to find the one that will be most effective for your dog’s training needs. Remember to always prioritize your dog’s safety and well-being when using a training collar and always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and recommendations. With patience, consistency, and the right training collar, you can help your stubborn dog become a well-behaved and obedient companion.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs That Actually Work